Written by 5:47 am Audiophile Music

The Beatles: Yesterday, Today… and Now

Lifelong Beatlefan Mark Smotroff decides to not to buy the latest Beatle box set. Here’s why….

AR-USBoxset_Packshot225x175.jpgYou’ve probably heard the news by now (oh boy) that it was some 50 years ago in 1964 when The Beatles first arrived– and almost instantaneously conquered — America. Accordingly, the first material tributes in what will no doubt be a series of many celebratory offerings around the birth and ascension of The Fab Four have been unleashed on the world. These include a quite curious boxed set — titled The U.S. Albums — compiling deluxe CD reinventions of every American-issued Beatle record in both Mono and Stereo incarnations. I say reinvention because these apparently aren’t quite the exact actual American mixes that were made back in the day but newer creations based on the decidedly better sounding 2009 remasters. It is beyond the scope of this review to go into the nuances of those differences but it is important to note that they are not the same. The track listings may look like the original American issues but they will play more like the better sounding 2009 remasters, which are based on the original UK mixes.

Got that?

Yeah, it is confusing and that is part of why I won’t be focusing on it. By the time you read this others will have already dissected this beastie for what it is and isn’t.

AR-butcherCDPEEL225x175.jpgThat said, The U.S. Albums boxed set is notable for the reissue, for the first time ever on CD, of the US versions of the soundtracks to the movies A Hard Days Night and Help. The Beatles Story, a sort of audio documentary disc that was issued at the height of Beatlemania, is also finally available for the compact digital format.

However, and perhaps controversially or compellingly depending on your personal stance on the issue, the most significant album included in the reissue is the Yesterday and Today collection from 1966. For those not in the know, up until the Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper album, most of the records issued in America did not exactly mirror those in the UK or the rest of the world. The US record market was attuned to 10-12 tracks per album, not 14. Also, in Britain, the practice of putting singles releases on LPs was viewed as redundant, so a slew of Beatle single releases were also prime for the cherry picking and placement into an LP.

Thus, enterprising business folk at Capitol Records decided it would be lucrative to squeeze extra albums from this track differential, padding out imaginary (if you will) albums that didn’t exist in the Beatles’ regular official UK and world catalog. Here in the US we were treated to a mishmash of Beatle songs presented in a manner that was often times wildly divergent from what the band had intended for us to hear. Some of these albums worked, some not so much. US-only titles included The Beatles Second Album, Something New, the two aforementioned movie soundtracks (which were padded with incidental movie music by producer George Martin in the US), Beatles VI, The Early Beatles and Beatles 65. The US versions of Rubber Soul and Revolver too were compromised presentations of The Beatles’ music.

AR-Y&T225x175.jpgCulled mostly from the Rubber Soul, Revolver and Help albums, Capitol Records issued in 1966 the Yesterday and Today collection amidst some controversy as the initial covers featured The Beatles wearing butchers’ smocks and holding dismembered baby dolls bloodied by slabs of raw red meat! For 1966, this was pretty shocking. Retailers balked almost immediately and the albums were recalled and pasted over with a new, much tamer, image of the band and reshipped to the stores. These “butcher covers” have gone on to become among the most coveted of possessions among Beatle fans. You can read more about the controversy here.

Why am I telling you all this?

Well, in the box set — and for a limited time as an individual disc — Capitol has reissued a CD version of Yesterday and Today with the original butcher cover art and a very clever peel-it-yourself sticker of the replacement sleeve.

It is pretty cool, actually. Yet, at the end of the day — and I say this as a collector who still has never found a Butcher cover — it is but a cute trinket compared to the genuine article.

Now, I recognize that this is an audiophile publication so I have to make some time to talk about the sound on this disc which (as mentioned earlier) is based on the 2009 remasters. These recordings are not the US remixes that were used back in the 1960s, which often added reverb and compression to make the music ripe for the American listening audience (in theory). I’ll put it this way: this disc does not present the precise sound you older Beatle fans might remember. It is an approximation. That said, the CD sounds OK, with the mono mix winning hands down over the stereo counterpart due its tighter presentation of the music. To my ear, the new CD sounds a little brighter than corresponding tracks on the Beatles Mono CD Box set. From what I have been able to discern from other Beatlephiles, this CD mixes up a variety tracks from different sources so its a bit hard to make a blanket judgement.

At the end of the day, the CD sounds like Beatle music. I could go on but…. I mean… you, Dear Reader, are an audiophile, so you probably aren’t going to want to listen to your Beatles music off this CD anyhow! Am I right? Especially if it was made from a tweaked remaster of a 2009 remaster?

]]>AR-beat1.jpgWhen it comes to a straight reissue/restoration, I prefer to hear the songs presented in the best and most authentic presentation possible, as true to the original approved masters that The Beatles heard themselves back in the day.

The argument over whether it is a good presentation of Beatle music is a topic for another blog post (and probably another writer). I will go on record that Yesterday and Today is a mess! It places tracks from 1965 from Help and Rubber Soul head-to-head with tracks from punchier sounding 1966 sessions that spawned Revolver.

If you grew up listening to these songs the US sequenced way, you probably like it just fine. But if you’re like me, you’ve grown fond of the original UK track listings, which, in theory is the way the Beatles wanted you to listen to their music, then this collection (and all these hybridized American issues) will be a less to your liking.

If you are a Beatle fan, you WILL nonetheless want a copy of this cute little mini Butcher Cover for your collection. It IS a cool thing. But, personally, I am not going to invest a penny in this new U.S. Albums boxed set. Why should I? I have all the American issue pressings and frankly prefer listening to the full UK issues.

No, Dear Readers, what I am saving my money for is my dream box set; the reissues all the Beatles original MONO pressings on LP.

Actually, Dear Record Label Executives who might be reading, here is the thing you should do: release the albums in perfect, really high quality recreations of the original UK Mono LPs (and the later stereo ones, as uncompressed as possible). ALSO include in the package a Blu-ray with the original mono (and stereo mixes) in completely uncompressed uber-high resolution audio (96/24, 192/24, etc.) via formats like DTS HD Master Audio or Dolby TrueHD (or even LPCM if you prefer!). While you’re at it, throw in additional remixes of everything from Rubber Soul onward into discrete, immersive 5.1 surround sound and include that in the package as well!

I’ll bet The Beatles could sell a whole bunch of premium boxed sets like this for big dollars (ala The Smiths and Pixies box sets). That is certainly the type of set I would probably spring for…

AR-beat4.jpgIf you want to spend your Beatle bucks more wisely today, get the really lovely LP version of Paul McCartney’s latest album, New, arguably one of his best records in many a year. The LP sounds much better than the 16-bit versions I’ve heard and has fabulous packaging including a beautiful LP-sized booklet with great pictures of the band ‘n other cool stuff. It also comes with an MP3 download.

If you want a higher resolution experience — and now that I have the LP in hand, I have done some quick comparison of key tracks — the HDTracks download of New sounds the best of the available options, with more pronounced low end and crisper definition at the high end. The LP delivers a more compressed flavor to it (which makes some sense), though not offensively so. I’ll put it this way — I’ll keep the album and will probably play it numerous times because playing records is more fun than a download! But the high res download does sound pretty great and the deluxe version comes with two additional tracks not found on the LP (“Turned Out” and “Get Me Out of Here”) so you kinda really do need both versions if you are a Beatle completist.

And for the most part I’m something of a Beatle completist, in case you haven’t figured that out yet.

Yeah, yeah, yeahhhh…

Mark Smotroff is a freelance writer and avid music collector who bought his first record at approximately age five with saved-up birthday money — a 45 RPM single of “She Loves You” by The Beatles on Swan Records. Several years later he bought his first LP (again, with his own savings), Magical Mystery Tour by The Beatles. Smotroff has worked for many years in marketing communications for the consumer electronics, pro audio and video games industries, serving clients including DTS, Sega, Sony, Sharp, AT&T and many others. www.smotroff.com Mark has written for EQ Magazine, Mix Magazine, Goldmine/DISCoveries Magazine, BigPictureBigSound.com, Sound+Vision Magazine and HomeTechTell.com. He is also a musician / composer whose songs have been used in TV shows such as Smallville and Men In Trees as well as films and documentaries. www.ingdom.com Mark is currently rolling out a new musical he’s written: www.dialthemusical.com.

(Visited 1,089 times, 8 visits today)